In an era where consumers are spoiled for choice, and AI agents increasingly act on behalf of human customers, every digital interaction has become a make-or-break moment. One glitch in a login flow, a clunky verification step, or an interface that simply doesn’t feel secure can send customers fleeing – often for good.
While price and product once dictated loyalty, businesses are now finding that trust has become the decisive factor in retaining customers. And, increasingly, that trust is built (or broken) through modern digital identity systems.
A recent survey of 1,000 Australian adults revealed a decline of trust among Australians alongside rising security concerns in the age of AI. The report found that just 11% have “full trust” in the organisations that manage their identity. Trust is eroding quickly, with a majority (82%) reporting more concern about personal data security than they felt five years ago, alongside growing demand for stronger authentication and tighter government regulation.
Seamless experiences win loyalty
Consider a familiar journey. A consumer spots a product on social media, clicks through to an online store, and adds it to their cart. They don’t buy immediately but return later using another device.
If the cart contents are still there, and if they are remembered and not forced to log in again, the experience feels effortless and personal. That small moment of convenience can convert a casual browser into a repeat customer.
This frictionless flow is powered by customer identity and access management (CIAM) platforms. Mature CIAM systems underpin single sign-on (SSO), letting customers move between apps and devices without constant logins or lost sessions. They preserve continuity and reduce abandonment, turning convenience into competitive advantage.
The personal touch
CIAM also enables the kind of personalisation that customers increasingly expect. Recognising a returning customer by name, offering relevant recommendations, and pre-filling checkout forms signal that a brand ‘knows’ its users without demanding excessive data upfront.
Progressive profiling allows companies to collect information gradually, while identity orchestration co-ordinates that data across platforms. This helps prevent ‘form fatigue’ and builds trust by letting customers control what they share and when. The result is a sense of familiarity that feels empowering rather than invasive.
Conversely, broken experiences erode trust quickly. A failed password reset email, a shopping cart that empties every time a session expires, or a checkout that forces account creation can be enough to send customers elsewhere.
Registration and checkout remain among the highest-risk points for abandonment. Businesses that overload these moments with unnecessary identity checks or friction drive people away, sometimes permanently.
Security: A silent but critical factor
Trust isn’t only about convenience. Customers don’t want to be micromanaged, but they do want to feel protected, and adaptive multi-factor authentication (MFA) exemplifies this balance. Indeed, the Ping Identity 2025 global Consumer Survey found that the top features that would increase Australians’ trust in online brands are multi-factor authentication (cited by 47% of adults) and biometrics (cited by 34% of adults).
A bank app that allows frictionless access on a recognised device, but adds a verification step when a login comes from overseas, communicates protection without disruption. Indeed, the same survey cited above found that the leading change people want in their login experience is more biometrics (cited by 21% of adults).
Behind the scenes, risk signals such as device fingerprinting or behavioural biometrics help CIAM platforms determine when to introduce friction. Security becomes almost invisible, surfacing only when necessary.
When it works seamlessly, customers reward such discretion with loyalty, however the balance is delicate. If fraud prevention systems become blunt instruments, they can frustrate legitimate users. Worse, if fraud detection fails entirely, fake accounts, account takeovers and stolen loyalty points can erode confidence overnight.
Turning identity into trust
Modern CIAM systems do far more than authenticate legitimate users. They orchestrate entire digital identities, smoothing the customer journey from registration to checkout and beyond.
Three capabilities are key. First, CIAM enables intuitive access. Features such as social logins, biometric authentication and one-time passcodes remove the burden of passwords and fragmented logins, while still recognising returning users to allow personalisation.
Second, it delivers adaptive security. By analysing risk in real time, CIAM platforms can escalate security only when warranted (such as logins from new devices or unusual locations) without interrupting low-risk users.
Third, CIAM empowers customers to manage their own data. Built-in consent and preference tools show what data is collected, how it is used, and allow sharing preferences to be adjusted at any time.
Collectively, these capabilities transform identity from a backend checkpoint into a front-line customer experience driver.
The business case for trust
The commercial payoff from trust is tangible. Customers who feel safe and supported come back more often, spend more, and become brand advocates.
The costs of eroding trust are just as measurable. Failed logins, abandoned carts, and account recovery support inflate operational costs while fake accounts and loyalty fraud drain revenue. Breaches and account takeovers inflict lasting reputational harm. What begins as a technical shortcoming can quickly escalate into a financial and brand crisis.
Identity can no longer be treated as a backend IT function. It cuts across marketing, product development, security and customer support, and it must evolve continuously as threats, expectations and regulations shift.
A robust CIAM strategy begins by mapping the customer journey, identifying points of friction, and targeting them with identity solutions that simultaneously remove barriers and strengthen protection. This layered, proactive approach positions identity not just as a safeguard, but as a growth driver.
Customer loyalty is not won through flashy interfaces or clever messaging. It is earned through consistently secure, respectful, and easy-to-navigate experiences. Companies that understand this trust equation and optimize hybrid identity journeys through a framework that also secures agentic identities, will be the ones that customers choose to stay with.